TLDR The authors defended their methods for measuring hair density and caliber, emphasizing the need for consistent photography and manual counting for accuracy in evaluating hair loss treatments.
The authors of the study "The effect of platelet-rich plasma on female androgenetic alopecia: A randomized controlled trial" responded to comments from Kim et al. They defended their use of 50x and 100x magnification for measuring hair density and caliber, respectively, based on other trichographic literature. They emphasized the importance of standardization in photography for evaluating hair density and caliber, and noted that they used consistent lighting, hairstyling, and photography systems throughout their study. They also used a single investigator to manually count hair density on each magnified image, arguing that manual counting is more accurate than automatic counting. They agreed with Kim et al that standardized and consistent clinical photography is necessary to accurately evaluate the efficacy of various androgenetic alopecia therapies.
18 citations,
July 2020 in “Journal of The American Academy of Dermatology” PRP injections improve hair density and thickness in women with hair loss.
178 citations,
April 2017 in “Journal of The American Academy of Dermatology” Minoxidil, finasteride, and low-level laser light therapy effectively treat hair loss.
40 citations,
April 2006 in “Journal of the European Academy of Dermatology and Venereology” The Trichoscan system was found to be inaccurate for measuring hair growth, needing better software to be useful.
18 citations,
July 2020 in “Journal of The American Academy of Dermatology” PRP injections improve hair density and thickness in women with hair loss.
5 citations,
March 2022 in “Frontiers in Medicine” PRP is effective for treating hair loss, especially with other treatments.
11 citations,
May 2021 in “Dermatologic clinics” PRP and cell therapies may help with hair loss, but more research is needed.
12 citations,
May 2019 in “Aesthetic Surgery Journal” Platelet-Rich Plasma and stem cell therapy can increase hair count and density, but the best method for preparation and treatment still needs to be determined.
10 citations,
August 2020 in “Dermatologic Therapy” PRP improves hair thickness for both genders, but only increases hair density in men.