Motivations and Stake Management in Producing YouTube 'Bro-Science' Videos for Baldness Treatment

    Andrew McNeill, Elizabeth Sillence
    Image of study
    TLDR Creators of YouTube 'bro-science' baldness videos are driven by a need to share and persuade, often emphasizing authenticity and community building, while navigating trust issues related to commercial ties.
    The document from 2018 analyzed 72 YouTube 'bro-science' videos to understand the motivations behind creating and sharing content on baldness treatments. The creators were motivated by a sense of compulsion, desire to communicate product benefits, intention to share research, and wish to share personal experiences. They aimed to persuade viewers by demonstrating authenticity and managing potential accusations of vested interest, often by disavowing financial interest or admitting to a small commission for transparency. The study found that these videos serve a rhetorical function, creating a community around shared problems and solutions, and contributing to a shift in the traditional physician-patient relationship. The presence of commercial elements was noted to impact perceived trustworthiness, and the study suggested that the gendered nature of 'bro-science' may require further investigation.
    Discuss this study in the Community →

    Related Community Posts Join

    6 / 1000+ results

      community Hair loss treatment tier list by Dr Oscar Muñoz

      in Treatment  930 upvotes 1 year ago
      Dr. Oscar Muñoz's hair loss treatment tier list suggests oral minoxidil and finasteride are highly effective, while topical treatments like RU58841 and microneedling are less effective. Users discuss the effectiveness of various treatments, with some favoring oral options for their practicality and higher response rates.

      community Listen to anyone besides your Mom while fighting hair-loss

      in Satire  464 upvotes 5 years ago
      Hair loss treatments, with people sharing their experiences of trying to get help from family members and how genetics can affect the severity of hair loss. Treatments mentioned include finasteride, minoxidil, RU58841, scalp massage, whey protein and bleaching.

      community Hair greed made me switch to Dut too early

      in Chat  42 upvotes 1 year ago
      The user switched from finasteride to dutasteride for hair loss but faced increased shedding and anxiety, regretting not staying with finasteride longer. Other users shared mixed experiences, advising patience with dutasteride, as it may take up to a year to show results.

    Similar Research

    6 / 1000+ results