Lifestyle Drugs: Ethical and Practical Issues

January 2001 in “ PharmacoEconomics ”

Devora Mitrany

TLDR The article concludes that a balance is needed between individual healthcare needs and societal resources when it comes to lifestyle drugs, with a call for compassionate policy application.

The 2001 article examines the rise of lifestyle drugs, which are used to address conditions often considered under personal control, such as alopecia, obesity, and smoking cessation. These drugs are classified based on their use rather than their properties. The article discusses the difficulty in defining medical necessity and the distinction between treatment and enhancement, highlighting the ethical and practical issues that arise from the medicalization of lifestyle desires. It emphasizes the need for consensus on values and strategies among all stakeholders, including regulatory agencies, healthcare providers, insurers, and patients. The case of finasteride is mentioned as an example of a drug with both medical and lifestyle applications. The article stresses the importance of pharmacoeconomic studies to determine the cost-benefit of lifestyle drugs and suggests cost-sharing as a potential solution for equitable access. The conclusion calls for a balance between individual healthcare needs and societal resources, advocating for compassionate application of policies.

View this study on link.springer.com →

Discuss this study in the Community →

Related Community Posts Join

6 / 1000+ results

community Study of thousands of Fin users over 20 years finds no evidence of Fin induced sexual dysfunction

in Research/Science 370 upvotes 10 months ago

The conversation is about a finding that finasteride does not significantly increase the risk of sexual dysfunction, with users sharing mixed personal experiences regarding side effects.

community I am a dermatologist with a clinical interest in alopecia. AMA

in Will treatment work for me? 2 years ago

In this conversation, 4990 discussed various treatments for hair loss, including oral minoxidil, PRP, transplan, Jak inhibitors, Dutasteride, Finasteride, Olumiant, Ketoconazole, RU58841, microneedling, baricitinib, and CCCA. They recommended scalp biopsies in unclear cases of DUPA, twice weekly to twice daily shampooing for topical minoxidil users, and two sessions spaced one month apart with follow up at month three to determine the effectiveness of PRP treatment.

community 3 months min 5 % hairline is progressing

in Progress Pictures 93 upvotes 1 year ago

The post discusses the user's hair loss treatment involving daily use of 5% minoxidil, rosemary oil 2-3 times a week, derma-rolling twice a week, and daily vitamin D. A reply suggests the user to start using finasteride before hair falls out.

community Cassiopea Announces Very Positive Interim Analysis Phase 2 Results for Breezula® (Clascoterone) in Treating Androgenetic Alopecia

63 upvotes 6 years ago

Breezula® (Clascoterone) showed promising results in a Phase 2 trial for treating hair loss, being as effective as Propecia with no serious side effects. It might be released between 2021-2022, and a related acne treatment with the same active ingredient could be used in the meantime.

community I received a prescription for DUTASTERIDE CAP 0.5MG and to this day for 7 months I have been taking propecia, I am considering switching because I see that my shedding has not stopped, although I have results that I associate with topical minoxidil. Do they think it's time to move to DUTASTERIDE 0.

in Finasteride/Dutasteride 7 upvotes 8 months ago

A user has been taking Propecia (finasteride) for 7 months and uses topical minoxidil, but is considering switching to dutasteride due to ongoing hair shedding. Another person suggests that 7 months is not enough time to decide on switching medications.

community My change after 14 months of treatment. Oral propecia 1 mg per day and oral minoxidil, today I add minoxidil and topical propecia to the protocol

in Finasteride/Dutasteride 244 upvotes 1 month ago

The user experienced significant hair recovery after 14 months using oral Propecia (finasteride) 1 mg daily and oral minoxidil, and recently added topical minoxidil and topical Propecia to their regimen. The doctor recommended this combination to maximize results, and the user reported no side effects, noticing improvements by the third month.